Edition · July 1, 2024

Trump’s immunity win came with a giant asterisk, and the wreckage was immediate

The Supreme Court handed Donald Trump a major legal boost on July 1, 2024 — but it also sent his January 6 case back to square one, delaying accountability and opening a fresh fight over what counts as an official presidential act.

Trump got the headline he wanted, but not the clean exoneration his allies tried to sell. The Court’s immunity ruling protected some official acts while leaving the door open to prosecution for unofficial conduct, which means the criminal case over his 2020 election plot did not go away. The practical result was delay, more expensive litigation, and another example of Trump turning a court win into a mess of his own making.

Closing take

For Trump, the day was a win in the narrowest sense and a headache in the larger one: a legal shield that also stalled the case rather than ending it. That is very on-brand. The Court bought him time, but it did not buy him innocence.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Trump’s immunity win still blew up his election case

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

The Supreme Court said presidents have broad immunity for official acts, but it also sent Trump’s January 6 prosecution back to lower courts to sort out what was official and what was not. That gave him delay, not closure, and ensured the case he most wanted to disappear stayed alive.

Open story + comments