Edition · September 21, 2022

Trump’s Wednesday Took a Legal Beating

Two major blows landed on September 21, 2022: New York filed its civil fraud case, and a federal appeals court cut back Trump’s Mar-a-Lago shielding strategy.

September 21, 2022 was one of those days when Trump-world got hit from two directions at once: state prosecutors in New York detonated a sprawling fraud lawsuit against Donald Trump and members of his family, while a federal appeals court undercut his effort to keep classified Mar-a-Lago records out of investigators’ hands. One was a public financial-law body blow. The other was a serious procedural loss in the documents fight that has been hanging over him all summer. Together, they showed a legal posture that looked less like control and more like damage limitation.

Closing take

The throughline is ugly for Trump: the more he tries to lawyer these messes into submission, the more the record seems to harden against him. New York was not nibbling around the edges; it was asking for massive penalties and business restrictions. And in the Mar-a-Lago case, the court was not buying the idea that his special-master gambit should freeze the government out of classified material. Bad day, bad optics, bad trajectory.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

New York Turns Trump’s Money Machine Into a Fraud Case

★★★★★Fuckup rating 5/5 Five-alarm fuckup

New York’s attorney general filed a sweeping civil fraud lawsuit accusing Donald Trump, three of his adult children, and the Trump Organization of years of deceptive asset valuations and financial misrepresentations. The case seeks huge penalties and restrictions on Trump family business activity in the state.

Open story + comments

Story

Appeals Court Pops Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Shield

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

A federal appeals court granted the Justice Department’s request to resume using classified Mar-a-Lago records in its criminal investigation, narrowing the protection Trump had been trying to build with a special-master review. It was a sharp procedural loss in the documents case.

Open story + comments